You're looking at two vitamin D bottles-one says D2 (ergocalciferol), the other D3 (cholecalciferol). The price is nearly identical. But one raises your blood levels 87% more effectively than the other. Choose wrong, and you might stay deficient despite taking supplements daily.

What matters: not all vitamin D is created equal. The form you choose determines whether your levels actually rise or you just create expensive urine. Taking D2 when you need D3 is like using regular gas in a premium-only engine. It might work, but you're not getting optimal performance.

The reality is more nuanced than "just take vitamin D." D2 and D3 have different molecular structures, absorption rates, and staying power in your bloodstream. Plus, the newest research shows that vitamin D3 paired with K2 might be the optimization stack most people need-but supplement brands rarely explain why. What most people don't realize is that vitamin D without K2 can actually cause problems. This guide breaks down D2 vs D3, when K2 matters, optimal dosing by deficiency level, and which form actually works for your specific situation. Let's optimize from within.

Track Your Vitamin D Levels

Mito Health tests 100+ biomarkers including 25-hydroxyvitamin D, calcium, PTH, and bone health markers with physician-guided protocols to help you optimize immunity, bone density, and longevity. Our comprehensive panels provide personalized interpretation to identify vitamin D deficiency early.

View Testing Options →

Quick Decision Tree - Choose Your Vitamin D in 30 Seconds

Start here-what's your situation?

• General deficiency (levels <30 ng/mL)? Vitamin D3 5,000 IU daily

• Severe deficiency (levels <20 ng/mL)? Vitamin D3 10,000 IU daily (monitored)

• Maintenance (levels 30-50 ng/mL)? Vitamin D3 2,000-4,000 IU daily

• Vegan/vegetarian? Vitamin D3 from lichen (plant-based) 2,000-5,000 IU

• Taking high doses (>5,000 IU daily)? Vitamin D3 + K2 combo (100-200mcg K2)

• Prescribed D2 by doctor? Ask about switching to D3 (87% more effective)

• Bone health focus? D3 + K2 (MK-7) combo 5,000 IU + 100mcg

• On a tight budget? D3 only, 5,000 IU (skip K2 if needed)

Still not sure? Keep reading-we'll break down exactly why these recommendations work.

Vitamin D2 vs D3 - The Critical Difference

Let's cut through the marketing. Here's what the research actually shows:

Vitamin D2 (Ergocalciferol):

• Derived from: Irradiated mushrooms or yeast

• Raises blood levels: Baseline effectiveness

• Half-life: 2-3 weeks (leaves your system faster)

• Potency: 1x (reference point)

• Common in: Prescription vitamin D, fortified foods, vegan supplements

Vitamin D3 (Cholecalciferol):

• Derived from: Lanolin (sheep's wool) or lichen (vegan option)

• Raises blood levels: 87% more effectively than D2 [1]

• Half-life: 4-6 weeks (stays in your system longer)

• Potency: 1.87x compared to D2

• Common in: Most over-the-counter supplements, the form your skin makes from sunlight

The reality is-your body makes D3 naturally when sunlight hits your skin. D3 is the native form. D2 is a synthetic alternative that exists primarily because it's cheaper to manufacture and patent.

What most people don't realize: Taking 1,000 IU of D2 is roughly equivalent to taking 535 IU of D3. If your doctor prescribed 50,000 IU of D2 weekly (common for severe deficiency), you're getting the equivalent of about 26,700 IU of D3. That's why D2 prescriptions use such high doses-they're compensating for lower effectiveness.

Why D3 Outperforms D2 (The Science)

Here's where it gets interesting. Both D2 and D3 get converted in your liver to 25-hydroxyvitamin D-the form measured in blood tests. But the conversion efficiency differs dramatically.

The metabolic pathway:

1. You take vitamin D supplement

2. Your liver converts it to 25(OH)D (storage form)

3. Your kidneys convert 25(OH)D to 1,25(OH)₂D (active form)

4. Active vitamin D regulates calcium absorption, immune function, gene expression

Where D2 fails: D2 binds more weakly to vitamin D-binding protein (DBP) in your blood. This means it gets cleared from your system faster and doesn't maintain stable levels as well as D3 [2].

A landmark study compared 4,000 IU of D2 vs D3 daily for 3 months. Result? D3 raised blood levels to 45 ng/mL on average. D2 raised levels to only 24 ng/mL-still technically deficient [3].

The bottom line: Unless you're vegan and avoiding animal-derived supplements, there's no scientific reason to choose D2 over D3. The only exception is if insurance covers prescription D2 and you can't afford over-the-counter D3 (in which case, take the D2-some vitamin D is better than none).

Enter Vitamin K2 - The D3 Optimization Partner

Here's the catch with high-dose vitamin D3-it dramatically increases calcium absorption from your gut. That sounds great for bone health, right? But there's a problem. Where does that calcium go?

Without K2: Calcium might deposit in your arteries, kidneys, and soft tissues-exactly where you don't want it. This is called calcification, and it's linked to cardiovascular disease.

With K2: Calcium gets directed to your bones and teeth-exactly where you do want it. K2 activates two proteins (osteocalcin and matrix Gla-protein) that shuttle calcium to appropriate tissues [4].

Think of it this way:

• Vitamin D3 = Construction crew bringing calcium into your body

• Vitamin K2 = Foreman directing where the calcium gets deposited

• Without K2, the construction crew just dumps materials randomly

When you need K2:

• Taking >5,000 IU of vitamin D3 daily

• Focusing on bone health or osteoporosis prevention

• History of kidney stones or vascular calcification

• Over age 50 (K2 production declines with age)

When K2 is optional:

• Taking <5,000 IU of D3 daily

• Budget is tight (prioritize D3 first)

• Eating K2-rich foods regularly (natto, aged cheese, grass-fed butter)

K2 Forms - MK-4 vs MK-7 (Yes, It Gets More Complex)

If you've decided to add K2, you'll notice two forms on labels: MK-4 and MK-7. Here's the difference:

MK-4 (Menaquinone-4):

• Half-life: 1-2 hours (requires multiple doses per day)

• Dose: 45mg (yes, milligrams-much higher than MK-7)

• Best for: Bone health (most research uses this form)

• Found in: Animal products (chicken, egg yolks)

MK-7 (Menaquinone-7):

• Half-life: 72 hours (once-daily dosing works)

• Dose: 100-200mcg (micrograms)

• Best for: Cardiovascular health and convenience

• Found in: Natto (fermented soybeans)

The practical choice: MK-7 is more convenient (once daily vs 3x daily for MK-4) and effective at much lower doses. Unless you have specific bone health concerns and prefer the MK-4 research, go with MK-7 at 100-200mcg.

Dosing by Deficiency Level - What Actually Works

Your ideal vitamin D dose depends on your current blood level. Here's the breakdown:

Severe deficiency (<20 ng/mL):

• D3 dose: 10,000 IU daily for 8-12 weeks

• K2 addition: 200mcg MK-7 daily

• Retest: After 8-12 weeks to assess response

• Expected rise: +20-30 ng/mL over 3 months

Moderate deficiency (20-30 ng/mL):

• D3 dose: 5,000 IU daily for 8-12 weeks

• K2 addition: 100-200mcg MK-7 daily

• Retest: After 8-12 weeks

• Expected rise: +15-25 ng/mL over 3 months

Optimal maintenance (30-50 ng/mL):

• D3 dose: 2,000-4,000 IU daily

• K2 addition: 100mcg MK-7 daily (optional)

• Retest: Every 6-12 months

• Goal: Maintain 40-50 ng/mL year-round

High-dose optimization (targeting 50-80 ng/mL):

• D3 dose: 5,000-10,000 IU daily

• K2 addition: 200mcg MK-7 daily (required)

• Retest: Every 3 months initially, then every 6 months

• Caution: Monitor calcium and PTH levels-work with a doctor

Important: These are general guidelines. Individual absorption varies based on body weight, gut health, magnesium status, and genetics. Some people need 10,000 IU daily just to maintain 40 ng/mL, while others reach 60 ng/mL on 2,000 IU.

The Cofactor No One Talks About - Magnesium

Here's where optimization gets interesting-you can't activate vitamin D without magnesium. Every step of vitamin D metabolism requires magnesium as a cofactor [5]. If you're magnesium deficient, even high-dose D3 won't raise your levels effectively.

The problem: An estimated 50% of people are magnesium deficient. Symptoms overlap with vitamin D deficiency (fatigue, muscle weakness, mood issues), making it hard to tell which is the real problem.

The solution: If you're supplementing vitamin D, also take magnesium:

• Magnesium dose: 300-400mg daily (glycinate or malate for best absorption)

• Timing: Take with vitamin D for synergy

• Signs you need more magnesium: Muscle cramps, poor D3 response despite supplementation, constipation

Pro tip: If your vitamin D levels aren't rising despite high-dose supplementation, check your magnesium and vitamin K2 status before increasing D3 further. You might have a cofactor deficiency, not a D3 absorption problem.

Timing & Absorption - When to Take Vitamin D

Best time: With your largest meal containing fat

• Why: Vitamin D is fat-soluble-absorption increases 50% when taken with dietary fat [6]

• Ideal meal: Breakfast or lunch with eggs, avocado, nuts, or olive oil

• Avoid: Taking on an empty stomach or with just coffee

Morning vs evening:

• Morning: Preferred-mimics natural sunlight exposure and may support circadian rhythm

• Evening: Fine if that's when you remember-consistency matters more than timing

With or without K2:

• Together: Take D3 and K2 in the same dose (they work synergistically)

• Separate: Not necessary-no interaction issues

Storage: Keep in a cool, dark place. Vitamin D degrades with heat and light exposure.

Photo from Unsplash

Common Vitamin D Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)

Mistake #1: Taking D2 instead of D3

• The fix: Unless you're vegan or prescribed D2, switch to D3. Check your supplement label-it should say "cholecalciferol" not "ergocalciferol."

Mistake #2: Taking vitamin D without checking levels first

• The fix: Test your baseline 25(OH)D before supplementing. You might need 2,000 IU or 10,000 IU-guessing wastes time and money.

Mistake #3: Taking high-dose D3 without K2

• The fix: If you're taking >5,000 IU daily, add 100-200mcg of K2 (MK-7) to prevent calcium misplacement.

Mistake #4: Ignoring magnesium status

• The fix: Take 300-400mg magnesium daily. Without it, vitamin D can't convert to active form.

Mistake #5: Expecting instant results

• The fix: Vitamin D levels take 8-12 weeks to stabilize. Retest after 3 months, not 3 weeks.

Mistake #6: Stopping supplementation in summer

• The fix: Unless you're getting 20+ minutes of midday sun exposure (without sunscreen) on 40% of your body daily, you still need supplements year-round.

Vegan Vitamin D3 Options (Yes, They Exist)

Here's the catch for vegans-most D3 comes from lanolin (sheep's wool). But plant-based D3 from lichen is now available. It's molecularly identical to animal-derived D3 and just as effective.

Vegan D3 sources:

• Lichen-derived D3: Same potency as lanolin-based D3, fully plant-based

• Cost: Slightly more expensive ($15-25/month vs $8-15 for conventional D3)

• Brands: Garden of Life, Naturelo, Vitashine

Vegan D2 vs vegan D3:

• D2: Technically vegan, but 87% less effective

• D3 from lichen: Vegan AND equally effective as conventional D3

• Choice: Pay slightly more for lichen-based D3-the effectiveness difference is worth it

Vegan K2 options:

• MK-7 from natto: Naturally vegan (fermented soybeans)

• Look for: "MK-7 from natto" or "plant-based K2" on label

Optimize From Within

Join Mito Health's annual membership to test 100+ biomarkers with concierge-level support from your care team. Track your vitamin D, calcium, parathyroid hormone, and related biomarkers with repeat testing and personalized protocols.

Learn About Membership →

Testing Your Vitamin D Status

Here's a frustrating reality-vitamin D deficiency is invisible until you test. You can feel great at 15 ng/mL or terrible at 45 ng/mL. Symptoms don't correlate well with levels.

Testing options:

1. 25(OH)D Blood Test (Gold Standard)

• What it measures: Storage form of vitamin D

• Optimal range: 40-60 ng/mL (some experts prefer 50-80 ng/mL)

• Deficiency: <20 ng/mL

• Insufficiency: 20-30 ng/mL

• Cost: $30-60 for standalone test, included in comprehensive panels

1. At-Home Finger-Prick Test

• Convenience: Test at home, mail to lab

• Accuracy: Comparable to venous blood draw

• Cost: $40-80

• Brands: LetsGetChecked, Everlywell

1. Comprehensive Panel (Recommended)

• Includes: Vitamin D + calcium + PTH + magnesium + phosphorus

• Why: Shows full picture of calcium metabolism and cofactor status

• Cost: $100-200 standalone, or part of broader health panel

When to test:

• Baseline: Before starting supplementation

• Follow-up: 8-12 weeks after starting/changing dose

• Maintenance: Every 6-12 months once optimized

Curious where your levels stand? Get personalized insights with our comprehensive Advanced Panel ($349 for individuals, $668 for couples). We measure vitamin D alongside calcium, magnesium, PTH, and 70+ biomarkers. Our longevity doctors provide detailed interpretation and dosing recommendations. Explore our panels.

Special Populations - Who Needs More?

Older adults (>65 years):

• Why: Skin produces 75% less vitamin D from sunlight with age

• Recommended: 3,000-5,000 IU D3 daily + K2

Darker skin tones:

• Why: Melanin reduces vitamin D synthesis by 90-95%

• Recommended: 2-3x higher doses than lighter skin tones

Overweight/obese (BMI >30):

• Why: Vitamin D gets sequestered in fat tissue

• Recommended: 2-3x higher doses based on body weight

Inflammatory bowel disease (Crohn's, UC):

• Why: Malabsorption reduces vitamin D uptake

• Recommended: Higher doses + periodic testing, work with GI doctor

Kidney disease:

• Why: Impaired conversion of 25(OH)D to active form

• Recommended: Activated vitamin D (calcitriol) may be needed-work with nephrologist

Pregnancy/breastfeeding:

• Why: Increased demand for fetal development and milk production

• Recommended: 4,000 IU D3 daily (consult OB-GYN)

The Bottom Line - Your Vitamin D Action Plan

If you're still overwhelmed, here's your decision flowchart:

For 90% of people: Start with vitamin D3 5,000 IU daily (not D2). Add magnesium 300-400mg. Test levels after 8-12 weeks and adjust.

If you're taking high doses (>5,000 IU): Add vitamin K2 (MK-7) 100-200mcg daily to direct calcium properly.

If you're vegan: Choose lichen-based D3 (not D2). The small price premium is worth the 87% effectiveness boost.

If you're severely deficient (<20 ng/mL): Take D3 10,000 IU daily for 8-12 weeks, add K2 200mcg, retest, then adjust to maintenance dose.

If you're on a budget: Prioritize D3 over K2. Get the vitamin D levels up first, add K2 when finances allow.

Key Takeaways

• D3 is 87% more effective than D2 Cholecalciferol (D3) raises and maintains 25(OH)D levels far better than ergocalciferol (D2)

• Always choose D3 unless prescribed D2 Only reason to use D2 is if doctor prescribes it; ask about switching to D3

• Vegan D3 exists (lichen-based) No need to compromise on effectiveness with mushroom-derived D2

• Add K2 when taking high doses (>5,000 IU) Vitamin K2-MK7 directs calcium to bones, prevents arterial calcification (100-200mcg daily)

• Magnesium is required for D activation Every step of vitamin D metabolism needs magnesium; take 300-400mg daily

• Target 40-60 ng/mL 25(OH)D Not the "normal" >30 ng/mL; longevity practitioners target high-normal range

• Correction dose: 5,000-10,000 IU daily for 8-12 weeks Severe deficiency (<20 ng/mL) needs higher doses; retest and adjust

• Maintenance varies widely: 2,000-10,000 IU Genetics, skin tone, body weight, latitude all affect needs; testing is essential

• The optimal stack is D3 + K2 + Magnesium Peter Attia: "They're inseparable"; taking D alone is ineffective and potentially risky

Your biology is unique-some people need 2,000 IU to maintain optimal levels, others need 10,000 IU. Testing is the only way to know. Optimize from within.

Medical Disclaimer

This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. The information provided should not be used for diagnosing or treating a health condition. Always consult with your doctor or qualified healthcare provider before starting any new supplement protocol, making changes to your diet, or if you have questions about a medical condition.

Individual results may vary. The dosages and protocols discussed are evidence-based but should be personalized under medical supervision, especially if you have existing health conditions or take medications.

Related Content

• Raising Vitamin D Levels

• Magnesium With Vitamin D Synergy

• Vitamin D + Omega-3

References

[1] Tripkovic L, et al. Comparison of vitamin D2 and vitamin D3 supplementation in raising serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D status: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012;95(6):1357-1364. PMID: 22552031

[2] Houghton LA, Vieth R. The case against ergocalciferol (vitamin D2) as a vitamin supplement. Am J Clin Nutr. 2006;84(4):694-697. PMID: 17023693

[3] Armas LA, et al. Vitamin D2 is much less effective than vitamin D3 in humans. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2004;89(11):5387-5391. PMID: 15531486

[4] Maresz K. Proper Calcium Use: Vitamin K2 as a Promoter of Bone and Cardiovascular Health. Integr Med (Encinitas). 2015;14(1):34-39. PMID: 26770129

[5] Uwitonze AM, Razzaque MS. Role of Magnesium in Vitamin D Activation and Function. J Am Osteopath Assoc. 2018;118(3):181-189. PMID: 29480918

[6] Mulligan GB, Licata A. Taking vitamin D with the largest meal improves absorption and results in higher serum levels of 25-hydroxyvitamin D. J Bone Miner Res. 2010;25(4):928-930. PMID: 20200983

[7] Holick MF, et al. Evaluation, treatment, and prevention of vitamin D deficiency: an Endocrine Society clinical practice guideline. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2011;96(7):1911-1930. PMID: 21646368

[8] van Ballegooijen AJ, et al. The synergistic interplay between vitamins D and K for bone and cardiovascular health: A narrative review. Int J Endocrinol. 2017;2017:7454376. PMID: 29313934