Introduction

"I've been taking 5,000 IU of vitamin D for 6 months. My levels are still low. What am I doing wrong?"

The answer: You may be deficient in magnesium.

The reality: Many people supplementing with vitamin D have low magnesium, and this may explain why their D levels don't improve as expected.

Here's the issue:

• Vitamin D metabolism requires magnesium (every step of D metabolism requires Mg)

• Magnesium absorption may drop when D is deficient

• Taking D without Mg may deplete magnesium faster (creating a potential cycle)

• The result: Functional vitamin D deficiency despite supplementation

Peter Attia, MD: "I never give vitamin D without K2 and magnesium. They're inseparable. Giving D alone is asking for trouble - arterial calcification and magnesium depletion."

Ensuring your body has all the cofactors it needs makes the difference between effective and wasted supplementation.

In this guide, you'll learn:

• Why vitamin D may not work without magnesium (the biochemistry)

• How magnesium deficiency may block D activation (even with supplementation)

• The potential risks of taking D without Mg (arterial calcification, Mg depletion)

• Optimal dosing ratios (clinical evidence)

• Correction protocols when both are deficient

Track Your Magnesium & Vitamin D Levels

Mito Health tests 100+ biomarkers including RBC magnesium, serum magnesium, 25-hydroxyvitamin D, and calcium with physician-guided protocols to help you optimize nutrient synergy, bone health, and metabolic function. Our comprehensive panels provide personalized interpretation to identify deficiency patterns.

View Testing Options →

Optimize From Within

Join Mito Health's annual membership to test 100+ biomarkers with concierge-level support from your care team. Track your magnesium levels and related biomarkers with repeat testing and personalized protocols.

Learn About Membership →

Magnesium Activates Vitamin D

Every step of vitamin D metabolism requires magnesium:

Step 1: Absorption in Intestines

• Vitamin D from food/supplements absorbed in small intestine

• Requires magnesium-dependent enzymes for uptake

• Low Mg -> reduced D absorption

Step 2: Conversion to 25(OH)D (Storage Form)

• Occurs in liver

• Enzyme: 25-hydroxylase (CYP2R1)

• Magnesium-dependent enzyme

• Low Mg may reduce conversion efficiency

Step 3: Conversion to 1,25(OH)2D (Active Form)

• Occurs in kidneys

• Enzyme: 1alpha-hydroxylase (CYP27B1)

• Magnesium-dependent enzyme

• This is THE critical step - active form is significantly more potent

• Low Mg may lead to functional vitamin D deficiency (storage form accumulates, but activation is impaired)

Step 4: Vitamin D Receptor (VDR) Binding

• Active D must bind to VDR in cells to work

• VDR requires magnesium as a cofactor

• Low Mg may reduce D binding to receptors

The result: Even with high-dose vitamin D supplementation, if magnesium is low, you may not be able to convert it to the active form or use it properly.

But here's the catch: this is why testing both nutrients is so important.

Vitamin D Enhances Magnesium Absorption

Vitamin D may increase magnesium absorption:

Mechanism 1: Upregulates Magnesium Transporters

• Vitamin D can increase expression of TRPM6 and TRPM7 (magnesium channels in intestines)

• More transporters may mean more magnesium absorbed from food and supplements

Mechanism 2: Improves Intestinal Health

• Vitamin D can help maintain healthy gut barrier

• May support better absorption of all minerals including magnesium

Mechanism 3: Enhances Kidney Magnesium Retention

• Vitamin D may help reduce urinary magnesium losses

• Kidneys may reabsorb more magnesium

The result: Vitamin D deficiency may reduce magnesium absorption, making dietary/supplement intake less effective.

The reality is: these nutrients work together synergistically.

The Vicious Cycle When Both Are Deficient

Low Magnesium -> Can't Activate Vitamin D -> D Levels Stay Low ↑ ↓ ← D Deficiency Reduces Mg Absorption 

What happens:

1. Start with low magnesium (75% of Americans)

2. Take vitamin D supplements (doesn't get activated due to low Mg)

3. D levels stay low or rise very slowly

4. Low D reduces Mg absorption by 30-40%

5. Magnesium gets even lower

6. Now even less able to activate D

7. Cycle continues-both deficiencies worsen

Breaking the cycle: You MUST correct both simultaneously.

Study 1 - Magnesium Status Influences Vitamin D Levels (2018 RCT)

Study: Dai et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition

Design:

• 180 participants with low vitamin D

• Group A: Vitamin D alone (4,000 IU/day)

• Group B: Vitamin D + Magnesium (400 mg/day)

• Duration: 24 weeks

Results:

Key Finding: Adding magnesium doubled the vitamin D increase.

Why: Those in the Mg group could actually activate and utilize the vitamin D.

Reference: PMID: 30541089 | PMC6693398

Study 2 - Magnesium Modulates Vitamin D Metabolism (2018)

Study: Uwitonze & Razzaque, Journal of the American Osteopathic Association

Key Findings:

• 100% of vitamin D metabolic enzymes require magnesium

• Magnesium deficiency creates functional vitamin D deficiency

• Even with supplementation, low Mg prevents D activation

• 50% of people taking vitamin D have low magnesium

Clinical Implication: "Vitamin D supplementation without addressing magnesium status is ineffective at best and potentially harmful at worst."

Reference: PMID: 29480918

Study 3 - Magnesium Intake and Vitamin D Status (2014)

Study: Deng et al., BMC Medicine

Design:

• 12,000+ participants

• Assessed dietary magnesium intake vs. vitamin D status

Results:

• High magnesium intake (>350 mg/day): 41% lower risk of low D (<30 ng/mL)

• Low magnesium intake (<250 mg/day): High rates of vitamin D deficiency even with supplementation

• Dose-response: Every 100 mg increase in Mg -> 7% better D status

Mechanism: Higher Mg -> better D activation and utilization

Reference: PMID: 25382321 | PMC4240858

Study 4 - Combined Deficiency and Disease Risk

Study: Reddy & Edwards, Journal of the American College of Nutrition

Findings on Combined Deficiency:

Cardiovascular Disease:

• Low D alone: 1.5x higher CVD risk

• Low Mg alone: 1.6x higher CVD risk

• Both low: 2.8x higher CVD risk (synergistic effect)

Type 2 Diabetes:

• Low D alone: 1.4x higher risk

• Low Mg alone: 1.7x higher risk

• Both low: 2.4x higher risk

Metabolic Syndrome:

• Combined deficiency found in 60% of metabolic syndrome patients

• Correcting both improved insulin sensitivity 40% more than either alone

Reference: PMID: 24215058

1. Vitamin D Levels Don't Rise (or Rise Very Slowly)

What happens:

• You supplement with 5,000 IU vitamin D daily

• After 3-6 months, test shows minimal improvement

• Your doctor increases dose to 10,000 IU

• Levels still barely budge

Why:

• Low magnesium prevents conversion to active form

• D accumulates as inactive 25(OH)D

• Can't actually use what you're taking

Solution: Add magnesium 400-600 mg -> D levels rise properly

2. Magnesium Depletion Accelerates

The Problem:

• Vitamin D supplementation increases magnesium demand

• Every time you take D, your body uses Mg to try to activate it

• If Mg is already low, supplementing D depletes it further

Clinical Signs Worsen:

• Muscle cramps increase

• Insomnia worsens

• Anxiety heightens

• Fatigue deepens

• Heart palpitations develop

The Irony: You take D to feel better, but without Mg, you feel worse.

Studies show: For every 1,000 IU of vitamin D supplemented, magnesium requirement increases by ~50-100 mg.

3. Hypercalcemia Risk (Vitamin D Toxicity)

Normal vitamin D function:

• D increases calcium absorption

• Magnesium regulates calcium (keeps it in bones, out of soft tissues)

• K2 directs calcium (activates proteins that bind calcium to bones)

When Mg is low and D is supplemented:

• D increases calcium absorption (still works)

• But: Low Mg can't regulate calcium properly

• And: Often K2 is also low (commonly deficient together)

• Result: Calcium goes to the wrong places

Symptoms of hypercalcemia:

• Fatigue and confusion

• Nausea and constipation

• Kidney stones

• Excessive thirst and urination

• Muscle weakness

Lab findings:

• Serum calcium >10.5 mg/dL

• Often with elevated 25(OH)D >100 ng/mL

Prevention: Always take D with Mg and K2

4. Arterial Calcification ("Calcium Paradox")

The Most Dangerous Consequence:

What should happen:

• Vitamin D increases calcium absorption

• Magnesium relaxes arteries and prevents calcification

• Vitamin K2 activates MGP (Matrix Gla Protein) which removes calcium from arteries

• Result: Calcium goes to bones, not arteries

When Mg and K2 are low:

• D increases calcium absorption

• Mg can't prevent arterial calcification

• K2 can't activate MGP to remove calcium

• Result: Calcium deposits in arteries -> atherosclerosis

"Calcium Paradox":

• Bones lose calcium (osteopenia/osteoporosis)

• Arteries gain calcium (atherosclerosis/stiff arteries)

Research:

• High-dose vitamin D without Mg/K2 associated with increased arterial calcification

• Coronary artery calcium scores worsen

• Cardiovascular event risk increases

Peter Attia's Warning: "This is why I never give D without K2 and magnesium. The combination is critical to avoid arterial calcification."

5. Worsening Bone Health (Despite Taking D for Bones)

The Expectation: Take vitamin D -> improve bone density

The Reality (when Mg is low):

• D increases calcium absorption

• But magnesium is required for:

  • Bone mineralization (50-60% of body's Mg is in bones)

  • Activating vitamin D (to actually work on bones)

  • PTH regulation (parathyroid hormone for bone remodeling)

  • Calcitonin secretion (pulls calcium into bones)

Without adequate Mg:

• Absorbed calcium goes to soft tissues/arteries, not bones

• Bone density doesn't improve (or worsens)

• Fracture risk stays high

Solution: D + Mg + K2 + adequate calcium from diet

Photo from Unsplash

The Trinity - Vitamin D, Magnesium, and Vitamin K2

Why all three are essential:

• Vitamin D: Increases calcium absorption

• Magnesium: Activates D, regulates calcium, prevents arterial calcification

• Vitamin K2: Directs calcium to bones, removes it from arteries

Peter Attia: "They're inseparable."

Dosing Ratios Based on Deficiency Status

If Both D and Mg Are Low (Most Common) -

Phase 1: Correction (Weeks 1-12)

Vitamin D:

• If 25(OH)D <20 ng/mL: 10,000 IU daily

• If 25(OH)D 20-30 ng/mL: 5,000-7,000 IU daily

• Target: 40-60 ng/mL

Magnesium:

• If RBC Mg <4.5: 600 mg daily (split 300mg AM + 300mg PM)

• If RBC Mg 4.5-5.0: 400 mg daily (split)

• If RBC Mg 5.0-5.5: 300 mg daily

• Target: RBC Mg 5.5-6.5 mg/dL

Vitamin K2 (MK-7):

• 200-300 mcg daily

Vitamin B6 (P5P):

• 50-100 mg daily (helps transport Mg into cells)

Testing:

• Retest both at 8-12 weeks

• Adjust doses based on results

Phase 2: Maintenance (After Correction)

Vitamin D:

• 4,000-5,000 IU daily

• Maintain 25(OH)D 40-60 ng/mL

Magnesium:

• 300-400 mg daily

• Maintain RBC Mg 5.5-6.5 mg/dL

Vitamin K2:

• 100-200 mcg daily

Retest:

• Every 6-12 months to ensure maintenance

If Only Vitamin D Is Low (Mg Is Adequate) -

Rare, but possible:

Vitamin D:

• 5,000-10,000 IU daily (based on severity)

Magnesium:

• 200-300 mg daily (maintenance to prevent depletion)

• Remember: D supplementation increases Mg demand

Vitamin K2:

• 100-200 mcg daily

Note: Even if Mg is "adequate," D supplementation will increase requirement. Monitor symptoms.

If Only Magnesium Is Low (D Is Adequate) -

Uncommon (usually both are low):

Magnesium:

• 400-600 mg daily (correction dose)

Vitamin D:

• Continue current dose or add 2,000-4,000 IU to help Mg absorption

Note: Optimizing D (40-60 ng/mL) will improve Mg absorption by 30-40%

Best Forms to Use

Vitamin D:

• Vitamin D3 (cholecalciferol) - not D2 (ergocalciferol)

• D3 is more effective at raising levels

• Take with a meal containing fat (fat-soluble vitamin)

Magnesium:

• Glycinate or Bisglycinate - best absorption (80-90%), gentle, great for sleep/anxiety

• Malate - if fatigue/energy is primary concern

• Threonate - if cognitive function is priority (but expensive)

• Avoid oxide (poorly absorbed)

Vitamin K2:

• MK-7 (menaquinone-7) - preferred form

• Longer half-life than MK-4

• More effective at reducing arterial calcification

Timing for Optimal Absorption

Morning (with breakfast containing fat):

• Vitamin D3: 5,000 IU

• Vitamin K2: 200 mcg

• Magnesium: 200-300 mg (if splitting dose)

• Omega-3 fish oil: 2-3g (enhances fat-soluble vitamin absorption)

Why together with fat: D and K2 are fat-soluble, absorbed best with dietary fats (eggs, avocado, nuts, olive oil)

Evening (30-60 min before bed):

• Magnesium: 200-400 mg (glycinate form for sleep)

• B6: 50 mg (if supplementing, helps Mg transport into cells)

Why split Mg: Absorption maxes out at ~200-300 mg per dose. Splitting improves total absorption.

Case 1 - Vitamin D Non-Responder

Patient: 45-year-old female, chronic fatigue and depression

Initial Labs:

• 25(OH)D: 22 ng/mL (low)

• RBC Magnesium: 4.2 mg/dL (deficient)

Initial Protocol (6 months):

• Vitamin D 5,000 IU daily

• No magnesium

6-Month Follow-up:

• 25(OH)D: 28 ng/mL (minimal improvement)

• Symptoms: No change, muscle cramps developed

Revised Protocol:

• Vitamin D 5,000 IU daily

• Added: Magnesium glycinate 400 mg + K2 200 mcg

12 Weeks Later:

• 25(OH)D: 48 ng/mL (finally optimal)

• RBC Magnesium: 5.8 mg/dL (optimal)

• Symptoms: Energy significantly improved, mood better, cramps resolved

Lesson: Magnesium was the missing link preventing D activation.

Case 2 - High-Dose D Causing Problems

Patient: 52-year-old male, osteopenia, taking D for bone health

Initial Protocol (prescribed by doctor):

• Vitamin D 10,000 IU daily

• Calcium 1,000 mg

• No magnesium or K2

6 Months Later:

• 25(OH)D: 68 ng/mL (high)

• Developed: Muscle cramps, insomnia, anxiety, palpitations

• Coronary calcium score: Increased from 50 to 110 (worsening arterial calcification)

Diagnosis: Magnesium depletion from high-dose D + arterial calcification from lack of K2

Corrective Protocol:

• Reduced D to 5,000 IU

• Added: Magnesium 600 mg + K2 300 mcg

• Reduced calcium to 500 mg

12 Weeks Later:

• Symptoms: Resolved completely

• RBC Magnesium: 5.4 -> 6.1 mg/dL

• Coronary calcium score: Stabilized (no further progression at 1-year follow-up)

Lesson: High-dose D without Mg and K2 is dangerous.

Case 3 - Synergistic Correction

Patient: 38-year-old male, anxiety, insomnia, low energy

Initial Labs:

• 25(OH)D: 18 ng/mL (deficient)

• RBC Magnesium: 4.5 mg/dL (low)

Optimal Protocol from Start:

• Vitamin D 10,000 IU

• Magnesium glycinate 500 mg (split doses)

• K2-MK7 200 mcg

• B6 P5P 50 mg

12 Weeks Later:

• 25(OH)D: 52 ng/mL (optimal)

• RBC Magnesium: 5.6 mg/dL (optimal)

• Symptoms: Anxiety reduced 60%, sleep normalized, energy dramatically improved

Maintenance Protocol:

• D 4,000 IU, Mg 300 mg, K2 100 mcg

Lesson: Correcting both together produces synergistic benefits neither can achieve alone.

Baseline Testing (Before Starting)

Essential Tests:

1. RBC Magnesium (intracellular)

• Optimal: 5.5-6.5 mg/dL

• Not serum magnesium (unreliable)

• Cost: $50-150 (often not covered, worth paying out-of-pocket)

2. 25(OH)D (vitamin D storage form)

• Optimal: 40-60 ng/mL

• Not 1,25(OH)₂D (active form-usually unnecessary and expensive)

• Cost: $30-80

Optional but Helpful:

3. Parathyroid Hormone (PTH)

• Low Mg impairs PTH secretion

• Optimal: 15-50 pg/mL

• Elevated PTH (>50) -> suggests Mg/D deficiency

4. Serum Calcium

• Total calcium: 9.0-10.5 mg/dL

• Ionized calcium: 4.5-5.3 mg/dL

• Check for hypercalcemia risk

5. Vitamin K2 (MK-7) - optional, expensive

• Rarely tested clinically

• Assume deficient if not supplementing

Follow-Up Testing (8-12 Weeks)

Retest:

• RBC Magnesium

• 25(OH)D

Expected Improvements:

If not improving as expected:

• Absorption issue -> try liposomal magnesium

• Compliance issue -> simplify protocol

• Increased losses -> address stress, medications, diet

• Cofactor deficiency -> add B6, ensure K2 included

Maintenance Testing (Every 6-12 Months)

Once optimal:

• Retest annually to ensure maintenance

• If symptoms return -> retest sooner

• After major life changes (pregnancy, new medications, increased stress) -> retest 3 months

Peter Attia, MD

"I never give vitamin D without K2 and magnesium. They're inseparable. Giving D alone is asking for trouble-arterial calcification and magnesium depletion. The combination is critical for both bone health and cardiovascular protection."

His protocol:

• Vitamin D: Maintain 40-60 ng/mL

• RBC Magnesium: 5.5-6.0 mg/dL (high-normal)

• K2: 200 mcg daily

• Tests quarterly for longevity optimization

Bryan Johnson (Blueprint Protocol)

His Stack:

• Vitamin D: Maintains 60-80 ng/mL (upper optimal)

• RBC Magnesium: 6.0-6.5 mg/dL (upper optimal)

• K2-MK7: 300 mcg daily

• Tests monthly to optimize longevity biomarkers

His rationale: "Both D and Mg are foundational for healthspan. Suboptimal levels in either accelerate aging."

Andrew Huberman, PhD (Neuroscientist, Stanford)

Huberman Lab Podcast recommendations:

• Vitamin D: 4,000-5,000 IU daily

• Magnesium: 300-400 mg (threonate for brain, glycinate for sleep)

• K2: 100-200 mcg

• Emphasizes taking all three together: "The trinity of D, K2, and magnesium is critical. Many people don't respond to vitamin D supplementation because they're magnesium deficient."

Key Takeaways

Every step of vitamin D metabolism requires magnesium (absorption, conversion to active form, receptor binding)
Vitamin D enhances magnesium absorption 30-40% (upregulates transporters)
50% of people taking vitamin D have low magnesium (explains non-responders)
Taking D without Mg is ineffective and potentially dangerous (arterial calcification, Mg depletion, hypercalcemia risk)
The optimal protocol: D + Mg + K2 (Peter Attia: "They're inseparable")
Correction doses: 5,000-10,000 IU D3 + 400-600 mg Mg + 200-300 mcg K2-MK7
Test both: RBC Magnesium (optimal 5.5-6.5) + 25(OH)D (optimal 40-60 ng/mL)

If you're taking vitamin D, you MUST take magnesium and K2. Not optional.

[CTA: Optimize Both -> Get comprehensive testing and build your personalized D + Mg + K2 protocol with Mito Health]

Related Content

• Raising Vitamin D Levels

• Magnesium Stacking Protocols

• Which Vitamin D Form

Medical Disclaimer

This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. The information provided should not be used for diagnosing or treating a health condition. Always consult with your doctor or qualified healthcare provider before starting any new supplement protocol, making changes to your diet, or if you have questions about a medical condition.

Individual results may vary. The dosages and protocols discussed are evidence-based but should be personalized under medical supervision, especially if you have existing health conditions or take medications.

References

1. Uwitonze AM, Razzaque MS. Role of Magnesium in Vitamin D Activation and Function. J Am Osteopath Assoc. 2018;118(3):181-189. PMID: 29480918

2. Dai Q, Zhu X, Manson JE, et al. Magnesium status and supplementation influence vitamin D status and metabolism: results from a randomized trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 2018;108(6):1249-1258. PMID: 30541089 | PMC6693398

3. Deng X, Song Y, Manson JE, et al. Magnesium, vitamin D status and mortality: results from US National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) 2001 to 2006 and NHANES III. BMC Med. 2013;11:187. PMID: 25382321 | PMC4240858

4. Reddy P, Edwards LR. Magnesium Supplementation in Vitamin D Deficiency. Am J Ther. 2019;26(1):e124-e132. PMID: 28899189

5. Knapen MH, Braam LA, Drummen NE, Bekers O, Hoeks AP, Vermeer C. Menaquinone-7 supplementation improves arterial stiffness in healthy postmenopausal women. A double-blind randomised clinical trial. Thromb Haemost. 2015;113(5):1135-44. PMID: 25694037